The 10-point check
Why checking beats researching
You could read forty articles about diamonds and still get taken at the counter. Checking is different — it's three facts the industry can't argue with:
Certificates are verifiable
Every GIA and IGI report number looks up free on the lab's own site, in about 30 seconds. Grades stop being the seller's opinion and become a document.
Prices are public
Certified stones are listed online by the hundred thousand. Any quote can be benchmarked against an identical-spec stone in two minutes. Markup hates company.
Policies are negotiable
Returns, resizing, and itemized receipts cost the seller almost nothing — which is why good sellers put them in writing and shaky ones change the subject.
Nobody plans to overpay by $2,000. It usually happens with a smile, soft lighting, and a glass of champagne at the counter. The checks are how you enjoy the champagne anyway.
The short version, if you're reading this in the parking lot
- GIA or IGI report, number verified on the lab's site. No report, no deal — whatever the discount.
- Excellent cut, G–H color, VS2–SI1 clarity. The grades where the stone looks perfect and you stop paying for microscope bragging rights.
- Benchmark the quote. 1 ct natural ~$3,500–$6,000; 1 ct lab ~$600–$1,200 (loose, 2026). More than ~15% over: negotiate or leave.
- Written 30-day returns and a resize policy. Before money moves, not after.
- Insure it the week it's on her hand. About $1–$2 per $100 of value per year.
That's the skeleton. The ten checks put muscle on it — start with the certificate.